This story was updated on Tuesday, Oct. 27.
Five San Antonio City Council members have proposed an alternative to Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones' $442 million bond plan, deepening disagreements over how funding should be divided among districts and whether to include infrastructure improvements around the planned downtown Spurs arena.
In a memo Thursday to City Manager Erik Walsh, council members Sukh Kaur, Jalen McKee-Rodriguez, Ric Galvan, Marina Alderete Gavito and Marc Whyte proposed setting aside $124 million for citywide projects, including housing, greenway trails, an Animal Care Services kennel facility and $35 million for infrastructure in the planned downtown sports and entertainment district.
Jones wants the city to explore other funding sources for those infrastructure improvements, including state hotel tax revenue collected through the city's Project Finance Zone, rather than using bond money.
Other proposed projects include improvements around the Medical Center and Nelson Wolff Stadium.
The remaining $318 million would be divided among the city's 10 council districts using an existing formula based on roadway mileage and street conditions. Districts could then allocate their share toward streets, parks and other community improvements.
“We believe this structure provides essential flexibility, empowering each district to allocate funding across parks, community facilities, and street infrastructure to address unique, neighborhood-level needs,” the council members wrote.
Jones has proposed directing most of the bond funding toward Council Districts 1 through 5, which she says have historically received less infrastructure investment.
Her plan would set aside $75 million for affordable housing and direct 85% of the remaining funding — about $312 million — to Districts 1 through 5. The other five districts would share approximately $55 million.
Speaking Monday on TPR's The Source, Jones pointed to the city's recovery from severe storms in August as evidence of the need for infrastructure investment. She argued that some districts have fallen far behind others.
“I would argue if you did that, any serious evaluation of community needs in our community would probably show you that all of that money probably needs to go to two or three districts, not just for this bond, but for the next four or five,” Jones said. “Like that's how far some parts of our community are from others, and I would argue we are a stronger city when some parts of our community aren't so far behind.”
Council members have also disagreed over the size of the bond. Several previously supported a larger $750 million package, despite the possibility of a future property tax increase. The mayor and other members favored the smaller amount recommended by city staff.
The council members said their proposal would stay within the city's borrowing limit, “without requiring any increase to the City’s property tax rate.”
Separately, the memo calls for $208 million in drainage improvements, compared with the $175 million previously proposed by city staff. Both proposals would fund drainage improvements through stormwater utility fees rather than bond money.
The dispute has also extended to oversight of the bond program. On Oct. 22, City Council voted 7-3 to give itself final approval over three community chairs, ending the mayor's traditional authority to appoint them independently.
The vote nullified Jones' appointments of Port San Antonio CEO Jim Perschbach, Center for Health Care Services CEO Jelynne LeBlanc Jamison and San Antonio Food Bank executive Mario Obledo Jr. All three remain eligible for consideration.
Council members Sukh Kaur and Phyllis Viagran will review candidates and recommend three chairs for approval by the full council. Supporters of the change said it would give council members a greater voice in the process.
City Council is expected to revisit the bond package Thursday, Oct. 29. Voters would have the final say in May 2027.